INTRODUCTION: To assure the quality of the Natural Products Expo brand and to help preserve the integrity and meaning of the term "NATURAL," New Hope Natural Media has introduced a phased-in process that will not allow specific artificial ingredients in foods at Natural Products Expos.
This effort represents our attempt to be responsive to the many comments, suggestions and concerns from industry manufacturers, distributors, brokers and retailers.
These Ingredient Standards & Guidelines are updated and refined over time, and exhibitors are notified about the Ingredient Standards prior to contracting exhibit space.
COMMENTS: Please submit all questions or comments to standards@newhope.com.
STANDARDS: These are enforceable for all Expo exhibitors.
GUIDELINES: These are recommendations not currently enforced.
SECTION II.H of the New Hope Natural Media Natural Products Expo/Engredea Exhibitor Standards:
II.H: Product Ingredients / Not Allowed / Artificial Sweeteners / Foods / Standard:
The following sweeteners are synthetic, do not occur in nature, and will not be allowed as ingredients in food products (products with a "Nutrition Facts" panel) for exhibit on the Natural Products Expo tradeshow floor (NOTE: This standard does not apply to dietary supplements, which are products labeled with a "Supplement Facts" panel):
|
INGREDIENT |
E NUMBER* |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Ace-K |
E950 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
Short for acesulfame potassium |
|
Acesulfame potassium |
E950 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
The potassium salt of a derivative of acetoacetic acid |
|
Aspartame |
E951 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
A dipeptide made by esterification of aspartic acid and phenylalanine |
|
Equal® |
E951 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
See aspartame |
|
GMO Sugar |
|
Sweetener |
Sugar made from genetically modified sugar beets |
|
Neotame |
|
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
Chemical derivative of the peptides, aspartic acid and phenylalanine |
|
Nutrasweet® |
E951 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
See aspartame |
|
Saccharin |
E954 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
Saccharin is produced from purified, manufactured methyl anthranilate |
|
Splenda® |
E955 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
See sucralose |
|
Sucralose |
E955 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
Made from sugar by the chemical addition of chlorine atoms |
|
Sunett® |
E950 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
See acesulfame potassium |
|
Sweet 'N Low® |
E954 |
High-intensity artificial sweetener |
See saccharin |
*E numbers are used in the European Union (EU) to designate additives that have been reviewed for safety and allowed in foods. They appear on the label of products sold in the EU.
Exhibitors may have literature (sales sheets, fliers, brochures, catalogs, etc.) about food products that contain these artificial sweeteners, but those products, packaging and samples are not allowed for exhibit on the show floor.
II.I: Product Ingredients / Artificial Sweeteners / Foods / Guidelines
Most polyol sweeteners (with the exception of erythritol) occur in nature, but in commercial practice they are obtained from hydrogenation of simple sugars to create the finished form. Therefore, these sweeteners, which are often used in low-carbohydrate, low-calorie or restricted-calorie products, should not be labeled as "natural." There are few low-calorie, natural alternatives to these sweeteners. They may be described as chemically identical to the product that occurs in nature, but it is misleading to label them as "natural," since hydrogenation is not a natural process.
|
INGREDIENT |
E NUMBER |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Isomalt |
E954 |
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
|
Hydrolyzed starch hydrolysates |
|
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
|
Lactitol |
E966 |
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
|
Mannitol |
E421 |
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
|
Maltitol |
E965 |
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
|
Sorbitol |
E420 |
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
|
Xylitol |
E967 |
Polyol sweetener |
Made from hydrogenation |
There following natural sweeteners are available and compatible with natural foods and the natural and organic retail channel.
Acceptable natural sweeteners include:
Barley malt syrup
Beet sugar
Cane sugar (vegetarians have concerns about sugar filtered through bone char)
Dextrose*
Erythritol (polyol sweetener made from fermentation; available as certified organic)
Evaporated cane juice
Fructose*
Fruit pastes (raisin, date)
Glucose*
High fructose corn syrup*
Honey
Juice concentrates
Lactose
Lo han kuo
Maltodextrins*
Maltose
Maple syrup
Molasses
Rice syrup
Stevia and steviosides
Sucanat®
Thaumatin
Turbinado sugar
*Corn-based sweeteners may be derived from genetically modified corn seed. Manufacturers should use non-GMO sources for these sweeteners.
II.J: Product Ingredients / Artificial Colorings / Foods / Standards
Natural foods should not contain any artificial colors. The FDA regulates the use of Food, Drug and Cosmetic (FD&C) colors that are intensely colored compounds for use in foods. These are considered certifiable colors.
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
FD&C Blue 1 |
E133 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
|
FD&C Blue 2 |
E132 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
|
FD&C Green 3 |
E143 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
|
FD&C Red 40 |
E129 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
|
FD&C Red 3 |
E127 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
|
FD&C Yellow 5 |
E102 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
|
FD&C Yellow 6 |
E110 |
Coloring |
Synthetic pigment |
II.J.A - Product Ingredients / Artificial Colorings / Foods / Guidelines
Some non-certifiable colors, even though derived from natural sources, such as caramels and synthetic beta-carotene, should not be used in foods labeled as "all natural". Some caramel colorings are processed with sulfite and/or ammonia and should not be used in foods labeled as "all natural". Oleoresins may use synthetic solvents for their production.
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Beta-apo-8'-carotenal |
E160e |
Coloring |
Synthetic |
|
Beta carotene—natural identical |
E160a |
Coloring |
Synthetic—food should not be labeled as "all-natural" |
|
Caramel coloring, Classes II, III and IV |
E150c,d |
Coloring |
Processed with ammonia and/or sulfites |
|
Cochineal/carmine |
E120 |
Coloring |
Derived from the bodies of insects—should not be used in vegetarian products |
|
Paprika oleoresin |
|
Coloring |
Synthetic solvents used in production |
Acceptable natural colorings include:
Annatto extract
Aronia (chokeberry) juice
Beet juice
Beta-carotene from carrots
Black currant juice
Carrot juice, purple/black
Elderberry juice
Grape juice
Grape skin extract
Lycopene
Paprika
Purple potato juice
Red radish juice
Red cabbage juice
Riboflavin
Saffron
Turmeric
II.K: Product Ingredients / Artificial Flavors and Flavor Enhancers / Foods / Standards
Natural foods should not contain any artificial flavorings. Some non-U.S. products may contain "nature-identical" flavorings, which are considered artificial in the United States. These products should not be labeled as natural. Allowed flavorings must be labeled as natural and must have certification from the flavor manufacturer that the flavoring is natural. It is recommended that the specification be reviewed and that all non-flavoring materials also should be natural, as the U.S. FDA will certify flavorings as natural which contain synthetic non-flavoring ingredients.
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Artificial flavorings |
|
Flavoring |
Synthetic |
Flavorings
The use of any artificial flavorings in natural foods is not allowed for the trade show. Any products labeled with artificial flavoring or natural and artificial flavoring are unacceptable. Also, many imported products may contain "nature-identical" flavorings, which are considered artificial in the United States. These are also not allowed.
Allowed flavorings must be labeled as natural and must have certification from the flavor manufacturer that the flavoring is natural. It is recommended that the specification be reviewed and that all non-flavoring materials also should be natural as the FDA will certify flavorings as natural which contain synthetic non-flavoring ingredients.
II.K.A: Product Ingredients / Artificial Flavors and Flavor Enhancers / Foods / Guidelines
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Natural and artificial flavorings |
|
Flavoring |
Synthetic |
|
Nature Identical flavorings |
|
Flavoring |
Synthetic in the US |
|
Inosinates |
E630-E633 |
Flavor enhancer |
Synthetic |
|
Guanylates |
E626-E629 |
Flavor enhancer |
Synthetic |
|
Glutamates, including monosodium glutamate (MSG) |
E620-E625 |
Flavor enhancer |
Synthetic |
Acceptable natural flavorings and flavor enhancers include:
Natural Flavors with no artificial non-flavoring ingredients
Yeast (non-GMO)
Salt
II.L: Product Ingredients / Artificial Preservatives / Foods / Guidelines
Natural foods should not contain any artificial preservatives. Microbiological preservatives are used in foods for microbiological stability and for color and flavor stability, such as preventing rancidity. Stability may be achieved using a combination of heat, low pH, lower moisture (or water activity) or other means.
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Ascorbic acid |
E300-E302 |
Preservative |
Synthetic as available commercially; should not label products all-natural |
|
Benzoates |
E210-E213 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
BHA/BHT |
E320/E321 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
EDTA |
E385 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
Malic acid |
E296 |
Preservative |
Should use L-version made from fermentation |
|
Nitrates/nitrites |
E250, E251 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
Proprionates |
E280-E283 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
Propyl gallate |
E310 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
Sorbates |
E200-E203 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
Sulfites |
E220-E226 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
|
TBHQ |
E319 |
Preservative |
Synthetic |
Acceptable natural preservatives include:
Acetates
Celery juice
Citrates
Citric acid
Mixed tocopherols
Natamycin
Nisin
II.M: Product Ingredients / Artificial Gums, Thickeners and Emulsifiers / Foods / Guidelines
Natural foods should not contain any artificial gums, thickeners or emulsifiers. Gums and thickeners are used in foods to provide texture, increase viscosity and to help with dispersion and stability of ingredients within a food matrix. There are many chemically modified gums available that should not be used in natural foods. Emulsifiers are designed to help stability of oil/water matrices, such as in salad dressings. Many are derived from synthetic ingredients or sources.
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Modified celluloses—ethyl, methyl, carboxy menthyl, hydroxypropyl, etc |
E461-E468 |
Thickener |
Synthetic |
|
Bleached lecithin |
E322 |
Emulsifier |
Synthetic |
|
Modified alginates—propyl, methyl, etc |
E405 |
Thickener |
Synthetic |
|
Polysorbates (or sorbitan esters) |
E432-E436; E491-E495 |
Emulsifier |
Synthetic |
|
Mono- and di-glycerides and their esters, such as DATEM |
E471-E472f |
Emulsifier |
Synthetic as they are derived from hydrogenated oils |
|
Esters of fatty acids |
E473-E479b |
Emulsifier |
Synthetic |
|
Modifed starches—corn, tapioca, etc. |
E1413-E1451 |
Thickener |
Synthetic |
|
Steroyl lacylates |
E481-E482 |
Emulsifer |
Synthetic |
Acceptable natural gums and thickeners include:
Agar
Carrageenan
Cellulose (unmodified)
Gellan gum
Guar gum
Gum Arabic
Konjac flour
Pectin
Pectins
Lecithin (unbleached)
Locust bean gum
Native starches—corn, tapioca, potato, wheat
Salts of alginic acid (sodium, potassium, calcium alginate)
Tragacanth
Xanthan gum
II.N: Product Ingredients / Artificial Bread Ingredients and Dough Conditioners / Foods / Guidelines
Breads for the natural products industry should be made with unbleached flours and preferably with whole grain flours, wherever possible. In addition, there are many ingredients used in the baking industry that are synthetic and should not be used in natural products.
|
INGREDIENT |
E Number |
FUNCTION |
WHY IS IT ARTIFICIAL? |
|
Bleached flour |
|
Ingredient |
Bleaching |
|
Potassium bromate |
|
Dough conditioner |
Synthetic |
|
Potassium iodate |
|
Dough conditioner |
Synthetic |
|
Azodicarbonamide |
E927b |
Dough conditioner |
Synthetic |
Acceptable natural bread ingredients include:
Ascorbic acid (should not be labeled as all natural as commercial ascorbic acid is synthetic)
Enzymes (should be non-GMO)
Unbleached flours
II.O: Product Ingredients / Genetically Modified Organisms (GMOs) / Foods / Guidelines
Foods containing ingredients made with genetically modified organisms may not be labeled as “natural” or “all natural.”
